“You’ve probably heard it a thousand times: ‘Judge not, lest you be judged.’ But if Jesus really meant never to judge anyone, why does He immediately tell us to ‘watch out for false prophets’ and judge them by their fruit? In Matthew 7, He isn’t banning discernment—He’s teaching us how to do it wisely.”
Judging by Fruit: What Matthew 7 Really Teaches
Many people know Matthew 7:1—“Judge not, lest you be judged” and think it forbids all judgment. But just a few verses later, Jesus tells us to judge people by their fruit (Matthew 7:15–20). The tension here is often misunderstood: Jesus isn’t forbidding discernment; He’s warning against hypocritical or self-righteous condemnation.
The key is understanding what “fruit” means and how we are called to evaluate it.
What Does “Fruit” Mean?
“Fruit” refers to the visible results of a person’s life, including:
-
Actions and character – How someone lives consistently over time.
-
Teaching and doctrine – Whether their guidance aligns with God’s Word.
-
Impact on others – Whether they encourage love, obedience, and growth, or spread harm and falsehood.
Jesus contrasts outward appearance with inner reality: a person may look righteous, but their fruit, what they produce in life, reveals their true nature.
Discernment vs. Condemnation
We are not called to judge hearts, only to exercise discernment over actions and outcomes.
-
Wrong judgment: Hypocritical, self-righteous, or harsh condemnation
-
Right judgment: Careful evaluation of fruit to recognize truth from error
“Remove the log from your own eye first” (Matthew 7:5) reminds us to start with humility and self-examination before assessing others. We are not to lean on our own understanding but on God's truth.
Examples of Fruit
| Bad Fruit | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| |||
| |||
|
| Good Fruit |
|---|
|
|
|
These patterns develop over time, not overnight. Evaluating fruit is about long-term observation, not snap judgments.
Actions Speak Louder Than Words
Jesus emphasizes that claims of faith are meaningless without corresponding action:
“Not everyone who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven…” (Matthew 7:21)
True faith produces consistent fruit. Evaluating life outcomes is the practical way we can follow Jesus’ teaching without overstepping God’s ultimate judgment.
So when people quote “Judge not, lest you be judged” to silence discernment, they miss the full picture. Jesus calls us to judge by fruit—to evaluate actions, character, and teaching, while avoiding hypocritical or heart-condemning judgment.
Discernment is not condemnation; it’s about recognizing truth, protecting the community, and following God’s guidance faithfully.
How Do You Judge by Fruit in Your Own Life?
So how do you judge by fruit in your own life? Start small: notice the patterns in the people you follow, listen to what their actions produce, and reflect on your own fruit. Are you growing love, obedience, and spiritual maturity, or something else? Discernment begins with observation, humility, and the courage to align your choices with truth.
* * *
Disclaimer: Some of the links in this post may be affiliate links (such as Amazon). If you make a purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.